ROME — Jews in the Italian capital have survived emperors, invasions, popes and fascists over the centuries. The decision to leave is not taken lightly, but it’s something being discussed again amid a rising tide of anti-Israel sentiment in Europe.
Rome’s Jewish community is modest — 13,000 to 15,000 people in a city of almost 3 million — but it is the oldest in Europe, with roots dating to the second century B.C. Its heart is the onetime Jewish ghetto on the banks of the Tiber River, which carries many tragic reminders of Oct. 16, 1943, when Nazi soldiers raided the neighborhood and sent more than 1,000 Roman Jews to their deaths in concentration camps.
The neighborhood has emerged over the past 20 years as a lively quarter with popular restaurants and bars, but that has been tempered in recent months by a visible increase in security and vandalism, including antisemitic symbols and slogans spray-painted on walls. Aggressive confrontations with Jewish students outside a school and at least one physical attack on Israeli tourists in the city have been reported.
“The Jews of Rome have been through a lot in their history,” said Marco, a Jewish waiter in his 50s working at one of the restaurants that thrives behind the Great Synagogue of Rome. He spoke on the condition that he not be fully identified.
“We can feel an old tension rising,” he told The Washington Times. “I haven’t heard of anyone who’s left because of what’s been happening. But people talk about it. Relatives in New York and Israel come up in conversation more often. It’s a possibility that’s coming into focus.”
The experience isn’t limited to Rome.
Sympathy for Israel spiked across Europe in the wake of the Hamas attacks on Oct. 7, 2023, but that quickly morphed into growing anger over the suffering of Palestinians at the hands of the Israeli military.
Data from the Armed Conflict Location & Event Data Project, a nonprofit monitoring organization, shows that European countries have hosted hundreds of pro-Palestinian demonstrations each month over the past year. Most have drawn tens of thousands, and some even hundreds of thousands. Though most demonstrations have been peaceful calls for a ceasefire and solidarity, some have resulted in clashes with police, arrests and damage to Jewish cultural sites.
“Jews have had to develop an innate capacity to understand when to respond to political, economic and cultural crisis situations,” Daniel Staetsky, a social statistician and director of the London-based European Jewish Demography Unit at the Institute for Jewish Policy Research, said in an interview.
“It’s easy to believe now that Jews in Germany in the 1930s should have known to leave, but you must remember that when Adolf Hitler came to power in 1933, nobody knew the ‘Final Solution’ would come in 1939. Still, around half of Jews left,” Mr. Staetsky said. “The same thing with the fall of the Soviet Union in 1989.”
Analysts say trends indicate that Jews again are fleeing Europe.
“There are four main ways to measure antisemitism,” said Italy-born Sergio DellaPergola, a professor emeritus specializing in Jewish population studies at The Hebrew University of Jerusalem. “You can ask Jews if they feel they are victims of it, you can ask the general public if they think there is antisemitism, you can count the acts of violence, or you can interpret what is found in the media and on social networks.”
All four metrics, Mr. DellaPergola said, produce different results, though all the data shows that the situation in Europe is moving in the same direction. The main difference is the rate at which it’s approaching what he called “an unprecedented level of hostility by modern standards.”
Gunther Jikeli, a professor of Germanic and Jewish studies at Indiana University, told The Washington Times that recent events are putting European Jews in a nearly impossible predicament.
“The lines between anti-Zionism and antisemitism are becoming blurrier every day,” he said. “This doesn’t happen in other contexts. People disagree with the Israeli government, and that’s fine. But many countries have terrible governments; look at Iran. But you don’t see people lashing out at Persian restaurants.”
His research has shown a dramatic increase in reported European antisemitic acts and in violent acts against Jews or Jewish institutions since the start of the Israel-Hamas war in 2023. Though data for last year is still being collated, he said, preliminary results show a flattening in the number of incidents from the peaks in 2023 and 2024, though still well above the prewar baseline.
“I think most European Jews like their home and they want to stay,” he said. “But, at the same time, many must be asking themselves, ‘Do my children have a future in my country?’”
The plight of European Jews earned headlines last month after Robert Garson, a British-born lawyer working closely with President Trump, announced he was discussing a possible offer of asylum to British Jews. He said Britain “is no longer a safe place” for its Jewish community. So far, no formal asylum has been proposed.
The statistics from Mr. Jikeli and other sources show an increase in antisemitic violence in Britain in line with trends in France, Germany and other European states.
Information from the Israeli Interior Ministry shows that about 3,300 French Jews left their country to move to Israel last year under Aliyah, Israel’s Law of Return. That was an increase of nearly 50% from the previous year, according to reports. Overall emigration data for 2025 will not be complete for several months.
Mr. DellaPergola, the professor emeritus, said the prospect of emigration for European Jews has one problem that didn’t exist in the 1930s, 1980s or other periods of crisis.
“Where should they go?” Mr. DellaPergola asked. “If I’m a Jew in Rome, should I go to Paris? It’s even worse there. From Paris to Brussels? That’s even worse.
“Do I go to the United States? That’s nearly impossible now because there are very stringent immigration standards. Even if they offer asylum to a few British Jews, that is grotesque, because this is a situation that cannot be solved because Uncle Sam offers 25 new immigration permits.
“What about Israel?” the professor asked. “It’s a country at war. Canada or Australia? They are very nice countries, but antisemitism is on the rise everywhere.”
Please read our comment policy before commenting.