‘GOAT’ review roundup: Critics split on Steph Curry’s animated basketball underdog tale

Sony Pictures Animation’s “GOAT,” a basketball-themed underdog story produced in part by NBA star Stephen Curry, opened in theaters Friday to a mixed critical response. While reviewers widely praise the film’s energetic animation and upbeat spirit, many say its familiar story keeps it from reaching championship heights.

The animated comedy, featuring the voices of Caleb McLaughlin, Gabrielle Union, Nick Kroll and Mr. Curry himself, centers on a determined young goat chasing basketball glory. Critics agree the movie delivers fast-paced action and visual flair — but they’re divided on whether the screenplay can match its style. 

Strong Visuals, Familiar Playbook

Several outlets applauded the film’s colorful animation and kinetic basketball sequences, calling it visually inventive and lively. Some reviewers described it as an inspiring, family-friendly sports story with positive messages about perseverance and self-belief. 

ScreenRant’s Gregory Nussen wrote that “a movie that has no shortage of pre-chewed clichés probably shouldn’t work, and yet, it resoundingly does. … a really effective, stunningly animated, inspiring success.”

Nell Minow, of RogerEbert.com, wrote that the movie features “vibrant artwork and a dynamic camera,” which “are more memorable than the generic character designs, not to mention the familiar storyline about doing what it takes to achieve your dreams.”

---

SEE ALSO: Culture Wire: Steph Curry’s animated movie releases, ‘John Wick’ game confirmed and more

---

Others also agreed that the film follows a predictable underdog formula, leaning heavily on well-worn sports-movie tropes. A number of critics noted that while the animation pops off the screen, the narrative itself rarely surprises.

A Divided Scorecard

On review aggregation sites, “GOAT” has landed in mixed territory, reflecting the split among critics. More enthusiastic reviewers praised the voice performances and heartfelt moments, while harsher takes labeled the film overly loud or emotionally shallow.

“It’s not as funny as it thinks it is and tiresome in its overly familiar redemption arc,” wrote Mark Kennedy of The Associated Press.

The consensus, if there is one, seems to be that “GOAT” is an energetic entry into the animated sports genre that may appeal most strongly to younger audiences and basketball fans, even if it doesn’t fully win over critics.