OPINION:
In New York City, one of the most restrictive places in America for lawful gun ownership, residents are signing up for concealed carry classes in record numbers. Recent reports show tens of thousands have applied for permits since the Supreme Court’s 2022 Bruen decision forced the state to relax its long-standing rules. In just three years, monthly applications have increased nearly tenfold.
The surge makes one thing clear: When given the opportunity to exercise their constitutional right to self-defense, law-abiding citizens are ready to take responsibility for their own safety. Whether they are accountants, teachers, veterans or business owners, Americans are showing that personal protection and public safety go hand in hand.
Yet across the country, millions of responsible gun owners still face a confusing patchwork of state laws that can turn ordinary travelers into accidental criminals. A woman with a clean record and extensive training in Pennsylvania can become a felon simply for crossing into New Jersey with her legally carried firearm, even if she is only passing through.
This is why Congress must pass H.R. 38, the Constitutional Concealed Carry Reciprocity Act. Reciprocity doesn’t eliminate state authority. It simply ensures that the fundamental right to self-defense travels with the citizen and doesn’t disappear based on ZIP code.
Critics warn that national reciprocity would “create a gun safety nightmare.” The facts show the opposite. Concealed carry permit holders are among the most law-abiding citizens in America. Lawful gun owners complete fingerprinting, background checks and training requirements, including the 16-hour course New York now mandates, to carry responsibly.
When responsible adults are barred from carrying legally, criminals benefit. Reciprocity strengthens deterrence; it doesn’t weaken safety.
Opponents also argue that reciprocity “adopts rock-bottom standards.” In reality, the bill leaves states free to set requirements for their own residents. It simply ensures that a lawful permit in one state is recognized in another.
Far from hindering law enforcement, reciprocity could improve clarity. Instead of navigating a maze of differing state laws, officers and citizens would share a predictable national standard.
At its core, this debate is about trust. Do we trust trained, background-checked Americans to responsibly exercise their right to self-defense? Or do we continue to criminalize them for political convenience?
Every American has the right to defend life and liberty. That right should not stop at a state line. It’s time for Congress to pass H.R. 38.
ROB CHADWICK
Director, personal and public safety, United States Concealed Carry Association
Orlando, Florida
Please read our comment policy before commenting.