MUSKEGON, Mich. (AP) - The Michigan appeals court has affirmed the conviction of a man in the disappearance and death of a gas station clerk in western Michigan.
Some evidence found at Jeffrey Willis’ home should have been excluded at trial, the court said, but it doesn’t outweigh other “strong untainted evidence” that showed he was responsible for Jessica Heeringa’s death.
“The cumulative effect of these relatively minor errors … did not deny defendant a fair trial,” the court said Thursday in a 3-0 opinion.
Heeringa, 25, disappeared in 2013 while working at a gas station in Norton Shores in Muskegon County. Her body hasn’t been found.
The appeals court found no problem with prosecutors telling jurors about Willis’ connection to the death of another woman, Rebekah Bletsch, and the attempted kidnapping of a teenager.
“The trial court did not err by determining that the other-acts evidence was relevant to whether Heeringa’s disappearance was a manifestation of (Willis’) common plan,” the court said.
Bletsch, 36, was fatally shot while jogging in 2014. Willis, 49, is serving life sentences for both deaths.
Willis was arrested in 2016 when a teen said he tried to abduct her. The arrest jump-started investigations of the Bletsch homicide and Heeringa’s disappearance.
Please read our comment policy before commenting.